Survey of US Political Economy

     Please Link to, Use for Teaching and Share

Prelude

Five Political Eras 1778-1932          Economic History 1900-2017

Prelude:

American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America

With distinct identities
 and values,
 they formed a shaky pact
in hopes of 
 slowly growing into
 one nation.

by Colin Woodard
September 25, 2012


buy the amazon.com

 

 

 

 

 

1. The First Nations 

2. El Norte 

3. New France 

4. Yankeedom 

5. New Netherlands

6. The Midlands 

7. Tidewater 

8. Deep South

9. Greater Appalachia

10. The Left Coast

11 The Far West 

See a more complete summary of
American Nation

 

Five Political Eras

Important Events

1) Elections 1788-1824 England's Political Influence Finally Ends and the South Has Some Success in Controlling Northern Business.
The causes of the American Revolution began as a disagreement over the way in which Great Britain treated the colonies. Americans felt they deserved all the rights of Englishmen.

Federalists favored unity through a strong central government, close ties to Britain, a centralized banking system, and close links between the government and the men of wealth. These men should run government. Republicans, under Jefferson, Madison, and Monroe  strongly opposed Alexander Hamilton's Federalist agenda. They stressed being more of a Republic, where the individual is sovereign as opposed to democracy, where the sovereign is the group, the majority.

1) Executive privilege was used by G.W. to keep Jay Treaty documents from Congress. Other Presidents would claim the right, courts would sometimes have to decide legality. Think NSA data spying.
2) 1791 Whiskey Rebellion against federal taxes failed. It would be the first of many fights concerning federal government taxes. Think The Tea Party.
3) A Quasi-War with France was not escalated by Adams despite the desires of his Cabinet. He used the Alien and Sedition Acts to limited citizen rights as revolutionaries ravaged Europe. A few went to jail. It would be the first of many attempts to have a US President and Congress ignore the Constitution. Think the Pentagon Papers, Syria, ISIS and Iraq.
4) The "American System" of internal improvements like road- building, a national bank were needed to encourage productive Eastern enterprises. A national currency, initiated by Alexander Hamilton, was financed by the  "Tariff of Abominations. The tariff caused the Nullification Crisis
as states wanted to declare federal laws unenforceable. It caused Adams to be a one term president. The fight over tariffs hurt middle America and helped business. Tariffs continue until post WW II Free Trade Agreements took their place. Think 1994 North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) and 2015 Trans Pacific Partnership.

5) The First Barbary War, fought on foreign soil, stopped payment of tribute to Mediterranean pirates. War on Terror Begins.
6) Louisiana Purchase
of 1803 and 1819 and 1821 treaties brings U.S. Florida from Spain. Later we would use military force against Mexico to expand westward.
7) War of 1812 was to protect freedom of the Sea. It ended hostilities with Britain. In 1814, not being able to settle the fiscal problems caused by the war, the U.S defaulted on its debt.
8) The Bank of United States charter was not renewed in an attempt to limit business influence. But, importing goods required bank credit which required paying for the War of 1812. required such an institution. The battle of North/East business interest vs. South and West rural interest continues today. Think
Bailout Prevention Act and the Tea Party.
9) 1920 Missouri Compromise admitted Maine as a free state and Missouri as a slave state to postponed the pain. Think keeping the present peaceful by ignoring long-term government issues.
10 ) Monroe Doctrine
1823 keeps U.S out of European politics and vice versa until WWI.
2) Elections 1828-1852 Federalism vs. State's Rights and Democracy vs. Republican, the Fight Begins When the Democratic-Republican Party of the Jefferson became factionalized in the 1820's, Jackson's supporters began to form the modern Democratic Party. It hoped to pass political power from established elites to ordinary voters.  It supported the primacy of the Presidency over the other branches of the U.S. Federal government. They continued the Bank War by opposing the renewal of the charter of Alexander Hamilton's Bank of the United State. Democrats also opposed Whig sponsored  modernizing programs that they felt would build up industry at the expense of the taxpayerThese battles continue today!  Democrats fought the rival Adams and Anti-Jacksonian factions, which soon emerged as the Whigs. They were led by Henry Clay, who advocated the primacy of Congress over the Executive Branch as well as economic protectionism policies  of Northeastern industry. 1) Indian Removal Act of 1830 forced Indians westward.
2) 1933 Compromise Tariff solved the North-South fight over protectionism.
3) 1838 Mormon War ended with roughly 20,000 Mormons relocated.
4) A failed 1842 Impeachment attempt of J. Taylor occurred because he had used his Presidential veto to over ride Northeast bank and tariff issues. Previous Presidential vetoes had been on Constitutional grounds. It would be the first of a few politically motivated impeachment attempts. Think Obama impeachment poll.
5) Mexican War settled with the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, which increased the U.S. by a third. It resulted in Slave Power accusations. The  Oregon Treaty  acquired much of the Northwest territory. It would be six states. England got British Columbia.
6) Compromise of 1850 postponed Civil War again and 1864 Kansas Nebraska Act increased tensions. Think postponing government budget problems.
3)Elections 1856-1896 Civil War Ends, Northeast Takes Control, The Gilded Age is Built on the Backs of the Poor, Especially Women, Immigrants, and Blacks  The civil War was followed by massive industrialization centered on rail roads, canals and steamships. Massive wealth was created. Farm mechanism lowered the cost of food and this coupled with science made for a somewhat more prosperous middle class. Immigrants suffered. 1) Panic of 1857 was caused by over-consumption of goods from Europe which lowered the money supply. Also overbuilding by competing railroads and rampant Western land speculation caused speculative problems.
Think
2008-9 Great Recession home building. 
2) Why we fought the Civil War.
3) Enforcement Acts of 1870-71 designed to protect blacks from the  Ku Klux Klan and to protect Indians failed.
4) Panic of 1873  was caused by the Coinage Act of 1873. It lowered the money supply. Workers blamed cheap foreign labor. Called the Long Depression until the 1930's when the Great Depression, it caused much hardship. It would not be the last time immigrants were blamed for problems. Think Mexico, United States barrier.
5) Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883 added merit and began the replacement of the spoils system in the federal hiring equation.
6) Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 lasted until 1942.  Scott Act of 1888 expanded the restrictions on Chinese immigration. Think current Mexican Immigration issues.
7) Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 began an attempt to regulate business trusts to harness their use of monopoly power.
8) McKinley Tariff of 1890 set record for high rates. Profits increased as did the price of consumers goods.
9) Panic of 1893 resulted in a  severe depression. Reluctantly J.P. Morgan bailed out the gold standard with $60,000,000. The 1894 Wilson–Gorman Tariff lowered tariffs slightly & created a 2% income tax on over $4,000 ($88,100 in 2010 dollars).  It was repealed as unconstitutional by the 1895 Supreme Court.

4) Elections1896-1928  Progressives  and Populists Finally End the Gilded Age, but Business Power Would Return After WW I. The 1896 realigning election resulted in a republican forged conservative coalition consisting of businessmen, professionals, skilled factory workers, and prosperous farmers. There would be opposition which created two unsettled decades called the 
Progressive Era. It was a period of social activism and political reform that flourished from the 1890s to the early 1920s.
See Progressive Era 15 min. video
One main goal of the Progressive movement was eliminating corruption in government by exposing political machines and their bosses in hopes of creating a more direct democracy.  This put election reform high on the agenda. Progressives also sought regulation of monopolistic trust corporations through antitrust laws which were seen as a means to promote fair competition for the benefit of consumers. An increase in post WW I Communist and Union activities caused a fear of anarchy not seen since the French Revolution. It led to public desire for a return to more peaceful Republican led government. It would not be the last Red Scare. 

1) The 1898 Spanish–American War was caused by colonial empire desires and business interests.
Dingley Tariff Act promoted industry at the expense of consumers as the tariff was paid by consumers.
The Gold Standard protected savers, but its inflexible money supply caused hard times.
2) The Panama Canal acquisition of 1903 eventually resulted in improved transportation.
3) Progressive Republican FDR successfully fought party Trusts. First with the 1906 Meat Inspection Act and Pure Food & Drug Act. The Hepburn Act increased Interstate Commerce Commission regulation of Rail Road Trusts, which still managed to control rates and competitors.
4) American Antiquities Act of 1906 created National Monuments and was one of many conservation activities.
5) Panic of 1907 needed help from both J.P.  Morgan and the Treasury as more liquidity was needed than his wealth could provide. The 1913 the Federal Reserve System resulted and it became the Lender of Last Resort. Designed by Wall Street bankers, the FED would continue under Wall Street's thumb until ... 2025 and counting! Think Great Recession.
6) Democrat Woodrow Wilson would continue a progressive the agenda. 
The Revenue Act of 1913 substituted income taxes for tariffs and this lowered the price of consumer goods. The Federal Trade Commission Act of 1914 was a major effort to control business trusts.
The Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914 outlawed specific conduct putting teeth into Sherman Antitrust Act.
The Federal Farm Loan Act of 1916 increased credit to rural family farmers and the Keating–Owen Act of 1916 temporally lowered child labor abuses.
7) Segregated government continued as
Wilson was like progressives T Jefferson, T Roosevelt, and D. Eisenhower in  that he felt Americans were not ready for integration.
8) Revenue Act of 1921 and Revenue Acts of 1924,1926,1928 reduced  taxes so only richest 2% paid  income taxes. Think 2 Bush tax cuts. The Fordney McCumber Tariff Act was one of many  protectionist measures during the decade. Smoot–Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 to protect US industries failed to help as Canada, France and others retaliated. A Mexican Repatriation program help unemployed Mexican citizens return home. It represented  forced migration. Think current immigration problems.
9)  Great Mississippi Flood of 1927 resulted in the Flood Control Act of 1928.
It created the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to watch over public infrastructure..
10) The 16th, 17th, and 19th amendments made some progressive policies permanent.

5) Elections 1932  Party Control Flip Flops Like a Yoyo, but progress Is Made. Republicans were penalized by outrage caused during the summer of 1932 by Veteran Bonus Army deaths.  It, combined with Hoover's domestic policies meant change was needed.

Democrats were anchored in a coalition of specific liberal groups, especially ethno-religious constituencies (Catholics, Jews, African Americans). White Southerners, well-organized labor unions, urban political machines, progressive intellectuals, and populist farm groups were also courted.
The Good  he Good  
1. Health Problems Solved
1902 Scarlet Fever deaths peaked at close to 5,000 and then slowly dropped thanks to penicillin.  
1905 Last Yellow Fever epidemic killed 20 in US as misquote control eliminated cause. 1936 vaccine ended disease.
1916 Measles 12,000 mostly children died. Vaccine finally eliminated most cases by early 1980's.
1918 Spanish Flu 500,000 died in US. This could have been the cause of the post WW 1 recession.
1921 Diphtheria 206,000 cases, 15,520 deaths, mostly children died.
1953 Polio 57,628 cases with 21,000 paralyzed Vaccine followed and Polio is now about gone. 
1957-58 Asian Flu  70,000 died in US.
1968-69 Hong Kong Flu 34,000 died in US.
1985-95+ AIDS killed ten to twenty thousand per year in 1970's.  Annual  deaths peaked at 41,699 in mid 1990's and then they quickly dropped due to super drug development and availability. Total US deaths were  658,507. 
By the 1960's
Measles, Mumps,  Rubella and a 1995 Chicken Pox vaccines made childhood safer and more enjoyable as did seat belts, infant safety seats, bicycle safety helmets, and 1962 began the era of government sponsored child protective services.
2. Long-lasting Great Depression Legislation
TVA employed people to build dams, controlled floods, improved irrigation and eventually generated electricity. Emergency Banking Act establish the first federal bank regulations and set up SEC to police Wall Street.  Social Security Act created Old-Age pensions, unemployment insurance and disability Insurance. Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 set maximum hours and minimum wages. It also prohibited Discriminatory Employment related to federal employment.
3. Post WW II Activity Included Reorganization of Israel resulted in a strong pro-American Middle East democracy.  
Marshall Plan prevented a repeat of the post WW I problems that led to WW II. Germany, Japan and England eventually prospered.  
NATO
officially ended Monroe Doctrine isolationism. 
Federal Aid Highway Act created interstate highway system for national defense purposes and allowed the development of suburbia.
4. A return to Progressivism Economic Opportunity Act of 1964 provided benefits for poor people, education, unemployed and the elderly. 
Civil Rights Act of 1964 finally began the process of moving toward minority equality. It continued with the Voting Rights Act of 1965  designed to assured minority registration and voting and  the Civil Rights Act of 1968 which banned housing discrimination. Social Security Amendments of 1965 created Medicare and Medicaid. 
Environmental Protection Agency was created by presidential executive order. It along with the Clean Air Act Amendment of 1990 increased federal regulatory authority. 26th Amendment of 1971 lowered voting age to18 Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990...
5. Taxes dropped benefits increased Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981 cut most taxes. Tax Reform Act of 1986 lowered taxes on wealthy. Tax Cuts of 2001 lowered rates for many. 2003 tax cut was the first in a time of high war. 2003 Medicare Part D increase drug benefits.
2010 PPACA
resulted in more people being insured. See Crash Course: U.S. History 48 ten to fifteen minutes videos  Updated 8/9/17
The Bad

1. Interned American Citizens in 1942 consisted of 150,000 mostly Japanese men, women and children.
2. Cuban Missile Crisis continued a long Cold War.
 
3. Bailouts began 1975 New York City $1.3b paid back +interest 1979 Chrysler Motors $1.5b paid back +interest 1982 Oklahoma-based Penn Square Bank $65m 1984 Continental Illinois Bank bailout $14b 1980's Savings and Loan $124.6b [2]
2009-10 Great Recession TARP $24b, Detroit $16b
4. Less Regulation Causes Trouble
Financial deregulation began in early 1970's and culminated with Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act of 1999 which repealed the Glass–Steagall Act enacted after  the Great Depression.  Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000  minimized regulation of financial derivatives 
5. War on Terror1 was named by George Bush II and it finally stuck after six months of constant marketing. Attacks against the U.S. had been going on for many years and while an attack on American soil was terrible, putting this conflict of previous wars catastrophes, calling it a war is questionable.

The Ugly  U.S. Cost of War
1. Nineteen-month World War 1 killed 116,516 from all causes with 204,002 wounded in action. The resulting  peace treaty severely penalized Germany and divided the Ottoman Empire among the winners. These winners continued their 19th Century Western Colonialism, which planted the seeds for Arab Unrest.

2. Four year World War 2 killed 405,399  from all causes with 670,660 wounded in action. Losers were not punished.  Russian Bear having suffered
26.6 military and civilian deaths used their newly occupied eastern European territory to provide a protective buffer.
3. Three year Korean War killed 36,574 with 103,284 wounded in action. South Korea remained free. Japan felt safe and used a small defense budget to build industrial capital and rejoined the developed world. 43. The very long Vietnam War2 killed 58,220 with over 153,303 wounded with few important positive results.
As of 12/31/14 Afghanistan War killed 2,312 with 20,026 wounded with few important positive results. As of 5/29/12 Iraq War killed 4,425 with 32,223  wounded with few important positive results.

Author's Ramblings

1 The idea that Muslims Extremism is behind all military confrontations in the Middle East and Africa reminds me of the Cold War. Then, regime change in Egypt, Syria and Para military confrontations in Central and South American were all said to be inspired by Communist. Looking back, neither Egypt or Syria became Communistic and few of these conflicts resulted in communist governments. Local oligarchs looking to control lesser developed countries, needed money and the USSR would contribute to one side and the U.S. to the other side. Today, Conservative Muslims have the money!

2According to Henry Kissinger's biographer Walter Isaacson, President Johnson's reason for U.S. involvement in Vietnam was called the Domino Theory. The idea that Nation A falling to Communism would make it easier for Nation B to fall and then C would fall quickly. This idea was already being questioned when Nixon took offices. Henry's reason for taking six years and not the promised six months to withdraw from Vietnam was the importance of maintaining U.S. foreign policy creditability. No attempt was made to compare the importance of credibility in relation to South-East Asia with that related to Central Europe, the Middle East, Korea/Japan, Central America and at home. Statements that something will hurt the U.S. should always be followed by how, how much, in relation to what, at what cost ... About half of the U.S. Vietnam causalities occurred during the Nixon-Kissinger watch even though both men entered office thinking the Vietnam War was not winnable.

4/23/23 — Bichler and Nitzan hypothesize that as capitalists grow more powerful,
they become more fearful about losing their grip on power.